Sauder, J Arthroplasty 2020 - The AAHKS Clinical Research Award: No Evidence for Superior Patient-Reported Outcome Scores after Total Hip Arthroplasty with the Direct Anterior Approach at 1.5 Months Postoperatively, and through a 5-Year Follow-Up

The AAHKS Clinical Research Award: No Evidence for Superior Patient-Reported Outcome Scores after Total Hip Arthroplasty with the Direct Anterior Approach at 1.5 Months Postoperatively, and through a 5-Year Follow-Up

Sauder, Emerson, et al.·J Arthroplasty·2020·21 citations

Background

The direct anterior approach to total hip arthroplasty (THA) may result in superior early postoperative patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs). This study compared PROMs between THA patients treated with the direct anterior or posterolateral approach between 1.5 months and 5 years, using literature-derived patient acceptable symptom state (PASS) and minimal clinically important improvement (MCII) thresholds.

Methods

A propensity score match of 93 direct anterior patients to 93 posterolateral patients from a multicenter US collaboration (6 centers, 398 patients) was performed.
The Harris Hip Score (HHS), the Short-Form 36, and a Numerical Rating Scale for Pain were collected preoperatively, postoperatively (mean days: 47), and at 1, 3, and 5 years.
The proportion of patients reaching the HHS PASS, Pain MCII, and Function MCII in the direct anterior and posterolateral groups was compared using binary logistic regressions, controlling for age, gender, body mass index, and Charnley score.

Results

Direct anterior patients were less likely to reach the HHS PASS at the postoperative visit (P = .015; odds ratio = 0.454), but not at later visits (P > .082).
Direct anterior patients had no difference from posterolateral patients in their tendency to reach the Pain MCII postoperatively or at 1 year (P > .090).
The direct anterior patients were less likely to reach the Function MCII at the postoperative visit (P = .011; odds ratio = 0.422), but not at 1 year (P = .958).

Conclusions

No evidence was found of superior early postoperative PROM scores in THA patients treated with the direct anterior approach. No PROM differences were found at or beyond 1 year, indicating that patients reach similar final symptom states, regardless of surgical approach.

Supplemental

The AAHKS Clinical Research Award: No Evidence for Superior Patient-Reported Outcome Scores after Total Hip Arthroplasty with the Direct Anterior Approach at 1.5 Months Postoperatively, and through a 5-Year Follow-Up.